The Critique Magazine Logo
    • Popular
    • Latest
    The Critique MagazineThe Critique
    Login
    VOICES & STORIES

    Our Lake, Our Fish—But Never Truly Ours

    The Paradox of Lake Victoria and Uganda’s Betrayed Bounty

    By: Isaac Christopher Lubogo

    25 Jul, 2025

    Share
    Save

    There is something painful about hunger at a feast. Something tragic about poverty by the lakeshore. Something treasonous about exporting prosperity while importing suffering.

    This is the paradox of Lake Victoria—Africa’s largest freshwater lake, the pride of Uganda’s southern flank, the watery cradle of generations. We sing its praises in anthems and folklore. We call it our lake. But the truth glares like the sun on open water: our lake, our fish—but never truly ours.

    For centuries, lakeside communities in places like Katosi, Buvuma, Masese, and Kalangala lived symbiotically with the waters. Fishing was more than a trade—it was identity, inheritance, and a sacred ritual.

    But today, a cruel reversal is unfolding. Fishers are now fugitives. Canoes are burned. Nets are confiscated. Men are whipped in the name of conservation while foreign trawlers, licensed by the state, plunder the depths.

    Where once a boy could cast a net and feed his family, now he must bribe, beg, or risk arrest. The lake remains, but access has been militarised. The fish remain, but the people are locked out.

    According to the Uganda Bureau of Statistics (UBOS, 2024), fish and fish products earned Uganda USD 170 million (UGX 650 billion) in export revenue. Nile perch alone accounts for nearly 90% of that figure, bound for Europe, the Middle East, and Asia.

    Yet back home, a kilogram of Nile perch is unaffordable to the very fishermen who catch it.

    Fishing households survive on UGX 10,000–30,000 per week, while exporters profit in billions.

    Less than 5% of the fish value chain remains in local hands (FAO, 2023).

    This isn’t development. It is organised exclusion.

    It is a state celebrating foreign exchange while its children boil fish bones for soup.

    Uganda does not need to reinvent the wheel. Other nations have mastered inclusive and sustainable fisheries. Consider:

    Iceland, where fish exports contribute 11% to GDP, but with 90% of the value chain controlled by locals. Fishers are empowered, not persecuted.

    Namibia, where government policy mandates that all fish be processed locally before export. Community quotas are issued to local cooperatives, boosting fishers’ incomes by over 200% (World Bank, 2022).

    Indonesia, which reserves near-shore zones for small-scale, community fishing. This reform added USD 4 billion to GDP over ten years, while reducing overfishing (FAO, 2021).

    Uganda earns revenue, but leaks dignity.

    GDP Potential: What the Lake Could Deliver

    Let us imagine a just, locally anchored system. One where:

    Fishers process their catch.

    At least 25% of the fish is for domestic consumption.

    Taxes from fish exports are reinvested in lake communities.

    Projected Economic Impact (Annual Estimates):

    Sector Value in UGX USD Equivalent

    Community processing & value-addition UGX 300 billion USD 80 million

    Domestic market supply UGX 180 billion USD 48 million

    Employment & MSMEs UGX 150 billion USD 40 million

    Cooperative tax revenue UGX 20 billion USD 5.3 million

    Total Local GDP Potential: UGX 650 billion (USD 173.3 million)

    Ironically, this is nearly equal to current export earnings—but with the added benefit of grassroots empowerment, food security, and local wealth circulation.

    Instead, this value is siphoned away:

    By foreign-owned processing firms.
    Through corruption at the landing sites.
    Via export policies that prioritise foreign demand over national need.

    The Militarisation of Hunger

    The deployment of the UPDF Fisheries Protection Unit, while portrayed as conservation, has become a tool of fear. Fishers are not just regulated—they are hunted.

    While locals are beaten for using "illegal" nets, commercial boats operate unchecked under political patronage. These double standards reflect a dangerous economic apartheid: the lake is protected not for the people, but from the people.

    This is not conservation. It is colonialism wearing camouflage.

    Toward Redemption: What Must Be Done

    Uganda must reclaim its lake—not just physically, but ideologically. That requires bold structural reform.

    1. Community Quota System

    • Allocate fishing zones and licenses to registered community cooperatives.

    • Empower youth and women-led fishing enterprises.

    1. Mandatory Local Processing

    • Enforce domestic processing before export.

    • Provide cold storage, packaging tech, and subsidies to local processors.

    1. Domestic Consumption Priority

    • Reserve 25% of the catch for local markets.

    • Introduce fish into school feeding programs and public institutions.

    1. Demilitarise, Decentralise

    • Replace UPDF enforcers with civil lake stewards trained in ethics, ecology, and local law.

    • Establish a Fisheries Ombudsman to report abuse.

    1. Revenue Reinvestment

    • Pass a Lake Resource Benefit-Sharing Act to allocate fish revenue to infrastructure, schools, and health centres in lake regions.

    Epilogue: The Fish Must Come Home

    There is something profoundly unjust about a man who lives on the shores of abundance yet eats in hunger. There is something prophetic about a nation that exports its future while mortgaging its soul.

    Lake Victoria is not just a body of water. It is a test of whether Uganda is willing to honour the dignity of its people or continue selling its inheritance for temporary gain.

    ⁠Until the lake feeds its children,
    Until the fisherman becomes the first, not last
    Until policy bows to people and not profit—
    We shall continue to cry:

    Our lake.
    Our fish.
    But never truly ours.

    Cited Data & Sources

    Uganda Bureau of Statistics (UBOS), Statistical Abstract, 2024
    Food and Agriculture Organisation (FAO), State of World Fisheries, 2023
    World Bank Report on Namibia Fisheries, 2022
    Ministry of Agriculture, Animal Industry and Fisheries (MAAIF), Fisheries Policy, 2020
    Fisheries Training Institute Entebbe, Internal Report, 2023
    World Economic Forum: Blue Economy & African Sovereignty, 2022

    💬Comments(0)

    Sign in to join the conversation

    The Critique Magazine

    Copyright Notice: All rights reserved. All the material published on this website should not be reproduced or republished without prior written consent.

    Copyright to the material on this website is held by The Critique Magazine and the contributors. Any violation of this copyright will be subject to legal proceedings under intellectual property law.

    Navigation

    HomeGlobal WatchLatestPopularSubmissionsIssues

    Magazine

    AboutThe VerdictInner Reflection

    Copyright 2025 - The Critique Magazine

    Most popular

    1

    The Hair, the Faith, And the Law: When Dreadlocks Become Evidence of Devotion

    “No razor shall touch his head, for the locks of his hair are holy unto the Lord.”

    Arinaitwe Reagan

    2

    The Year Politics Didn't Disappoint (Us)

    Plot twists and cliffhangers, Africa-style: where the story's never over

    Asiimwe Esther Peace

    3

    The Death of Morality and the Loss of Values in African Politics

    Africa’s leadership crisis is not just political—it is ethical.

    ABESON ALEX

    4

    Beyond Politics: The Cry for Human Dignity and Justice

    When security forces turn their power against citizens, they betray the very oath that binds them to justice.

    ABESON ALEX

    5

    The Politics of Ignorance and the Wisdom of Enlightenment

    True education must transcend literacy; it must awaken consciousness.

    ABESON ALEX

    6

    The Mismanagement of Politics: Africa’s Enduring Development Crisis

    The future of Africa depends on one truth: the reform of politics is the foundation of development.

    ABESON ALEX

    7

    The Mountainous Journey of Uganda to the Next General Elections: To What Extent Will They Be Free and Fair?

    A reflection on Uganda’s upcoming elections, questioning fairness, accountability, and the integrity of a system where power referees itself.

    Akampurira Agapito

    8

    The Dispute

    Kakwenza—Pro or Contra: Two Voices, One Question—What Kind of Uganda Do We Want?

    The Critique Magazine

    9

    Agenda of the Stomach, Not of the People: The Crisis in Cameroon

    True liberation begins when leadership feeds the nation’s conscience, not its appetite.

    ABESON ALEX

    10

    Uganda’s Crisis Is Not Ignorance, but the Quality of Leadership

    Leadership without intellectual grounding is like a ship without navigation—it may move, but it will never arrive.

    ABESON ALEX